by Amanda E. Standerfer
In the spring of 2006, I was ready to throw in the towel. I had been the Library Director at the Helen Matthes Library (a city library serving around 12,300 in Effingham, Illinois) since 2001. My very first day on the job I had to cut about $30,000 out of the budget (we were already 2 months into the fiscal year), and our financial situation just went downhill from there. Four operating tax referenda failed between 2001 and 2004 (yes, we were gluttons for punishment). I decided that I had done all that I could to keep the ship from sinking and that there was not enough turnip blood to keep it afloat.
The Board of Directors, knowing that the ship was not only going down, but was also on fire, asked me for a proposal to cut front-line staff in order to balance the budget. They of course didn’t want to cut any more services or hours (we had already cut 16 operating hours and significantly cut services after the first referendum failed), but thought that we could “get by with less.” In this case, “less” meant fewer people at the Check Out Desk (read: management will now be working the desk).
Unbeknownst to the Board, I was already intending to resign. My decision stemmed not just out of frustration over the financial situation; my third child was due later in the year, and I wanted to be home. Plus, I knew the Board could hire a new director at a lower salary and save some money. (Not that I was getting rich, but every penny helps.)
Then it hit me. Cutting front-line staff was the exact opposite from what we needed to do. They were the ones holding things together. They were the ones the public knew and loved. If we ever wanted an operating tax increase, we needed to beef up what the public saw and instead trim back-end operations. And when it came to behind-the-scenes expenses, there was one white elephant: health insurance.
We’re a small library, and in 2006, we only had 4 people on the group health insurance. As many of you in HR know, the size and health of the group determine the rates you can get. In our case, a small, relatively unhealthy group meant high premiums. Taking this into account, I got together with another manager at the library, a talented former small library director who was also interested in being home with her children more, and devised a plan.
The plan
In our case, we had dual motivations: 1) to save the library money, and, 2) to maximize our time with our children. By turning the Library Director position into two part-time jobs, the library would save a little on salaries (two 40-hour jobs became one 44-hour job, with a front-line part-time circ clerk added to the mix at a lower rate of pay), and save a lot on health insurance (to the tune of $20,000/year), since neither of us would qualify as part-time employees.
The plan would go into effect right after I returned from maternity leave. We thought that this would be a good transition time, since I would be off and working remotely for three months and then return on a two-day a week schedule. The library’s new Operations Director (we decided we didn’t like “co-director,” so each used a different title) would take over some of my tasks while I was on maternity leave and begin her 24 hour/week schedule when my leave ended.
What we learned
Take a hard look at how the job is going to be split. In our case, the Library Director handed over duties to the new Operations Director (formerly Circulation/Information Desk Manager). In a domino effect, the Operations Director then handed over some duties to several other staff members at the circ desk. The Library Director remained the person to sign on the bottom line, responsible for all the legal and financial aspects of the library, along with the website, the Board of Directors, human resources, grant writing, and fundraising. The Operations Director took over day-to-day duties, including collection development/maintenance, daily staff supervision and evaluations, and building maintenance issues.
What we discovered was that these jobs should have been two full-time jobs in the first place! I didn’t spend a lot of time on the collection (should have, but just didn’t have the time!) or the building, so many things slipped through the cracks. Ultimately, I felt like I didn’t give away enough duties, so ended up working more than the agreed upon 20 hours/week. While this was OK with me, at first I was not being paid for my extra hours (the library simply didn’t have the money).
Be ready to defend your job-sharing arrangement to the public. We totally dropped the ball on this one. We live in a small, rural area and flexible employment was not common at the time (we were pioneers!). When the local newspaper got hold of my job-sharing proposal, they wrote up an article giving the impression that I was actually getting a raise to work fewer hours. Nothing was further from the truth! While I was receiving about $4,000 more than half of my previous full-time salary, that was to make up for the lost health insurance benefits (the new Operations Director as well). The newspaper also didn’t understand that the move came in the middle of a fiscal year, where the majority of that year I was full-time and would only spend about four months job-sharing. A simple news release and table could have explained all of that, but the damage was done, and the article was printed. The newspaper’s editor did write a “clarification” article, but it took a long time for the public to forget.
Communicate, communicate, communicate. The Operations Director and I had to let each other know what was going on, all the time. I relied on her to keep me informed about the day-to-day happenings in the library, and she let me know if my “big picture” planning was out of line with what the staff could accomplish. We coached each other a lot. She knew that my children went down for naps around noon and that I would respond to all of her emails at that time. It became a joke around the administrative offices to watch out when I got online, because the emails started flying! We often talked on the phone and even tried instant messaging from time to time.
Realize that it may not work out exactly as you planned. I worried a lot about the library when I wasn’t there. Guilt can be a powerful thing. I put a strong reporting plan in place so I would know what was going on each week, and we also had weekly manager’s meetings to discuss four topics: This Week, Problems, Head’s Up, and Something Good. We held monthly “big” manager’s meeting where we had an agenda and tackled larger, ongoing issues. Even with this in place, things still slipped through the cracks. Would they have anyway? Probably. Knowing that allowed me to sleep at night.
Ultimately, I think the job sharing arrangement worked out really well. The library ended up getting a grant that subsidized some of my extra hours in the library and another grant that allowed us to focus on marketing and long-range planning. We put a moratorium on referenda to take three steps back to patch the ship and put out the fires, and we saved the library some serious dollars over a two-year period when they were most critical.
I discovered that I had to be a lot more efficient and effective when I was at the library and had to be creative about how I worked on library projects at home. A strong strategic vision helped with all that, and ultimately our library passed an operating tax referendum in February 2008. While we won’t receive any of our increased funds (almost double our previous budget!) for another six months, our Board started implementing changes at the library right away, including increasing our operating hours, hiring a full-time circulation manager, and hiring an assistant director. Some other personnel changes happened about the same time, bringing my job-sharing arrangement to an end. Now I’m just a part-time director and my duties are split among two other staff members… but that’s another story.
—-
Amanda E. Standerfer recently accepted the position as Program Manager for the Southeastern Illinois Community Foundation with offices in Effingham and Mattoon, Illinois. This position will allow her elevate the position of libraries throughout the region, helping make them hubs of their communities. From 2001-2008, she was the Library Director at the Helen Matthes Library in Effingham, Illinois. She received her MLIS from the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign in 1999, and has a BA and MA in history from Eastern Illinois University in Charleston, Illinois. She lives in Sullivan, Illinois with her husband and three children. Amanda can be reached at amandas@effinghamlibrary.org.
Tags: balance, job-sharing, standerfer